How to Order and Get Your Cakes!

At Peschel’s, our cheesecakes are made by hand according to our century-old family tradition. Our unwavering commitment to quality means our process takes a little time, but it’s this attention to detail that ensures our organic cheesecakes are the best you’ll ever experience.

Weekly production windows enable our team to source the freshest ingredients and make the best cakes, so here's how it works:

Place your order before midnight on Mondays

We fulfill orders weekly, so be sure to get yours in by Monday at midnight ET. Then on Tuesdays we get to work! Your cakes will be ready by Wednesday for local pickup, local delivery, or national shipping.

Cakes are ready by Wednesday

Our cakes are ready for you on Wednesdays of every week. They are frozen so that they transport easily and stay fresh longer.

If you live locally in South Tampa, you can visit our pickup window or you can select local delivery and we'll send someone to drop off your cake. Simply select pick-up or delivery, along with a preferred pick-up and delivery time, at checkout. Cakes are delivered inside insulated bags with ice packs.

If you live outside of South Tampa, we can ship your cakes to you. Cakes ship frozen with dry ice through UPS. Be sure to select overnight or 2-day shipping to ensure your cakes stay frozen.

Note for Florida Residents: if you live outside the 8 mile radius of the Bakery Box Pop-Up Shop, you will have to select UPS shipping, but the 1 day-ground option is similar to the cost of local delivery since it is in-state.

Our Location at The Bakery Box

We have a retail pop-up shop every Wednesday from 12pm - 4:30pm at The Bakery Box located at 5226 South Dale Mabry Hwy, Tampa, Florida 33611.